EyesOn Design Awards 2010

by Joanna Scott www.cardesignnews.com


Designers from GM's California Advanced Design studio stand beside the GMC Granite concept. Click for larger images
The EyesOn Design judges included acclaimed designers from OEMs, independent design houses and academics
A jovial Wolfgang Egger stands beside the Audi A8
Frank Saucedo and Clay Dean accepted the award for the GMC Granite concept, winner in the 2010 Best Concept Vehicle category

Outstanding achievement in automotive design was recognized at the fifth annual EyesOn Design Awards held at the 2010 NAIAS in Detroit in January. Top honors were awarded to the GMC Granite urban utility vehicle in the Best Concept Vehicle category, and the Audi A8 luxury sedan for Best Production Vehicle.

Dr. Phillip Hessburg, President of the Detroit Institute of Ophthalmology
Wolfgang Egger accepts the Award for Design Excellence for the Audi A8
Revenge Verde Supercar was one of the contenders on the concept shortlist












































Frank Saucedo, Director of GM Design's California studio, and Clay Dean, Executive Director GM Advanced Global Design, accepted the award for the GMC Granite Concept and acknowledged the importance of recognition from their design peers.

Making its worldwide debut in Detroit, the Granite shows a new design direction for General Motors, and if brought to market would be the smallest GMC on the road. Dave Lyon, Executive Director of North American Interior and Global Cross-Brand Design has described the Granite as "a precision instrument wrapped in a protective, industrial case".

The GMC Granite beat off competition from the Nissan Mixim, Revenge Verde Supercar, and the Audi e-tron which were all finalists in the concept category.

Wolfgang Egger, head of Audi and Lamborghini design, was welcomed to the stage to accept the Award for Design Excellence for the 2011 Audi A8 in the production category. The judges commented on the exceptionality of the vehicle.

It is the second year in a row that Audi designers have been honored by the EyesOn Design judging panel after the Audi R8 V10 and Audi A7 Sportback Concept (awarded alongside the Cadillac Converj Concept) took glory in both award categories last year.

The Audi A8 stole the spotlight from the Bentley Mulsanne, Fiat 500, Ford Focus, and Lincoln MKX that all featured in this year's final shortlist.

Only vehicles debuting at the NAIAS qualify for the EyesOn Design Awards. Although the Audi A8 was unveiled at Miami's Design Week in November 2009, it is Detroit that proves to be the car's official global auto show debut.
A who's who in transportation and industrial design made up this year's judging panel of current and former design executives from automotive manufacturers as well as leading academics.

Tom Gale, founding chairman for the EyesOn Design Awards and former head of design for Chrysler (now retired), reinforced Michigan's prominence in automotive design. "Design is of fundamental importance to the economy of Michigan," he said. "Chrysler, General Motors, Ford, Hyundai, Toyota... all have large studios here, as do hundreds of suppliers who [contribute to] the design and engineering process. This makes Michigan the design centre of North America."

‘Willie' G Davidson, Senior Vice President and Chief Styling Officer of Harley-Davidson motorcycles. Click for larger images
Anne Asensio and the EyesOn Design Chief judges
Clay Dean (left) and Frank Saucedo accept the top honor
Photos: Eric Gallina, Brett Patterson

There was no doubt that a new sense of optimism was in the air at the Detroit Auto Show. William ‘Willie' G Davidson, Senior Vice President and Chief Styling Officer of Harley-Davidson motorcycles, and one of the chief judges of the awards, spoke of "a renaissance in design taking place right now". He said: "As this industry reinvents itself, design becomes more important to visually tell the story of the future. New alternative powertrains create new opportunities for designers to give birth to new design direction. I think that the challenge is going to be to develop vehicles that have strong brand identity and are ‘cool'. I've spent most of my life trying to do that with our two-wheelers. If these new style vehicles can get people emotionally wrapped up in them... [then] we're going to move forward."

EyesOn Design Chief judges Jack Telnak, Tom Matano and Willie G Davidson
Tom Matano and Anne Asencio

















Chief judge Tom Matano, Executive Director of Industrial Design at Academy of Art University in San Francisco, echoed the positive vibe. "Designers are always very optimistic about the future - you can see that on the show floor today," he said. Matano added that he was also impressed with the selection of smaller cars being shown at the Detroit Auto Show. He stated that while consumers had historically, never really had the passion to own small, economical cars, "now, they are the cars you really want to own and be proud of".

EyesOn Design panel judge Anne Asensio, Vice President Design Experience for sponsor Dassault Systèmes and former Executive Director of Advanced Design at GM, talked of an industry with "greater responsibility" and one that could "think beyond boundaries". About 80 per cent of the vehicles at this year's Detroit Auto Show had, according to Asensio, been designed using the company's CATIA software. Asensio rallied the designer audience and called for "fresh perspectives" and "innovative use of software" and stated that the automotive industry was in the midst of a revolution in design tools that would radically change its development, design and production processes. "Social innovation," Asensio commented, "is at the core of transformation."

The EyesOn Design awards are presented by the Detroit Institute of Ophthalmology (DIO) - an internationally recognized non-profit organization that supports the visually impaired and facilitates research related to the eye. The next EyesOn Design event - the Automotive Design Show with the theme 2010: The Evolution of Automotive Design - takes place in Michigan in June.
Read more

Mazda5 preview

















Mazda has given us a preview of the all-new Mazda5, the third generation compact MPV set to make its debut at the forthcoming 2010 Geneva Motor Show.

The exterior design of the new compact MPV obviously integrates elements seen on Mazda's ‘Nagare' concept car series created under Franz von Holzhausen, but it is also claimed to be highly functional, contributing to increased fuel economy and reduced drag.

Inside, the new model evolves the functionality of the previous model with rear sliding doors and a cabin that can accommodate up to seven passengers. It has been designed and developed to meet the needs of European families with active lifestyles, according to the Japanese automaker.

"In approaching development of the all-new Mazda5 our team aimed to create a new C-MAV that combines superb practicality with the superior environmental performance these modern times demand and a new expression in stylish design," Mazda5 program manager Hideki Matsuoka said.

The all-new Mazda5 will go on sale across Europe later this year.
Read more

Test Drive: 2010 Volkswagen GTI

By: Josh Sadlier , Associate Editor www.edmunds.com


Vehicle Tested: 2010 Volkswagen GTI 4dr Hatchback (2.0L 4cyl Turbo 6M)
Pros: Torquey turbo-4, invigorating engine note, nimble handling, premium-grade interior, supple and quiet ride, good fuel economy, roomy backseat, practical hatchback design.
Cons: Less power than many rivals, electric power steering could be sharper and livelier, stability control can't be defeated, a couple ergonomic quirks.

The most mature sport compact on the market, 2010 Volkswagen GTI is so different from other sport-tuned compacts that it almost belongs in its own class. Its sharpened suspension doesn't compromise its ride quality, which remains supple and sophisticated. Its turbocharged motor trumpets a sweet song when called upon, but is barely audible during normal cruising. And unlike its competitors, the GTI looks and feels more like a Lilliputian luxury car than a boy racer. This is the sport compact that you bring home to meet the family.

Not much has changed on the new-for-2010 "Mk VI" (sixth-generation) GTI, but little tweaks go a long way here. Whereas the previous GTI's styling was a bit bloated, this one has crisper lines and tighter proportions. The interior has been reworked, too, providing even more of an entry-level-luxury ambience than before. The "wasn't broke, didn't fix it" category includes the amazingly roomy backseat and practical breadboxlike hatchback body style. The only flaw VW chose not to correct was the GTI's power deficit relative to its steroidal peers.

Yes, that sweet-sounding 2.0-liter turbo-4 turns out to be the GTI's Achilles' heel — if speed is a top priority, that is. Rated at the same 200 horsepower and 207 pound-feet of torque as the Mk V GTI's engine, this well-mannered mill gets waxed at the drag strip by big-turboed bruisers like the Mazdaspeed 3's 2.3-liter four (263 hp, 280 lb-ft) and the Subaru WRX's 2.5-liter boxer-4 (265 hp, 244 lb-ft). The GTI's engine is less prone to turbo lag and more refined and fuel-efficient, but there's no denying its disadvantage in brute force.

So the GTI isn't the fastest sport compact on the block. No matter; it's still the one that will likely hold the most appeal for consumers who want a true all-in-one performance car. With its engaging personality, remarkable functionality and Audi-like polish, the 2010 Volkswagen GTI is in a class of one, and incidentally one of the best automotive values under $25,000.

  • 2010 Volkswagen GTI - Front

    The 2010 Volkswagen GTI is the most mature sport compact on the market. There's not a juvenile bone in its body.
    (photo by: Kurt Niebuhr)

  • 2010 Volkswagen GTI - Interior

    The plaid upholstery and VW badges are about the only elements that separate the GTI's interior from an Audi creation.
    (photo by: Kurt Niebuhr)

  • 2010 Volkswagen GTI - Rear

    The new GTI's taillights are tidier than the outgoing model's. Indeed, "tidy" is the word for the GTI's styling, from every angle.
    (photo by: Kurt Niebuhr)

Performance

The front-wheel-drive 2010 Volkswagen GTI is powered by a 2.0-liter turbocharged four-cylinder engine rated at 200 hp and 207 lb-ft of torque. Our test car had the standard six-speed manual transmission; VW's dual-clutch automated manual (DSG) is optional. EPA fuel economy estimates are a laudable 21 mpg city/31 mpg highway and 25 mpg combined (and the DSG is even better at 24/32/27).

At the test track, the GTI hit 60 mph in 6.9 seconds. That's marginally quicker than the last Civic Si we tested, but 0.5 second off the Mazdaspeed 3's pace and a whopping 1.7 seconds off the WRX's. The GTI negotiated our slalom course at a back-of-the-pack 67.1-mph pace, and skid-pad testing yielded a similarly indifferent 0.84g.

In the real world, the GTI's chassis feels a lot more capable than those numbers suggest, which tells us that the standard 17-inch all-season tires aren't doing it any favors. But we're not sure we'd spring for the optional 18-inch performance tires, as they might compromise the GTI's refined ride. A better bet would be to wear out the standard all-season tires and then replace them with performance rubber.

In any case, the 2010 Volkswagen GTI is a pleasure at anything less than 8/10ths. From behind the wheel, it feels tiny and tossable, and the supple suspension soaks up midcorner bumps that other sport compacts would find unsettling. Beyond better tires, we'd only wish for livelier responses from the electric power steering and a stability control "off" button that actually worked as advertised.

As for that supposedly underpowered engine, it certainly doesn't act the part. There's ample midrange torque, along with a linear high-rpm surge that's a rarity in the world of turbocharging; moreover, the GTI-specific intake design sends a glorious sound through the firewall under full throttle. The manual shifter has VW's traditional rubbery quality, but the transmission as a whole seems set up to ensure that you'll never miss a shift — it's extraordinarily user-friendly. Add it all up and you've got a thoroughly entertaining sport compact, regardless of those middling test results.

Comfort

The 2010 Volkswagen GTI cruises like a pint-size BMW. It's quiet and composed at all speeds, and the ride is firm but never punishing. The extensively contoured flat-bottom steering wheel feels great and wouldn't look out of place in the Audi R8supercar. Decked out in the GTI's trademark tartan fabric, the standard front sport seats provide an excellent combination of lateral support and long-distance comfort. Unlike many cars in this class, the GTI offers well-padded armrests all around.

The backseat is just as impressive given the GTI's diminutive dimensions (the Mazdaspeed 3 looks and feels almost like a midsize wagon by comparison). The fact that two 6-foot-plus adults can comfortably ride in back — with the front seats configured for their physiques, no less — is simply astounding. With accommodations like these, the GTI might even merit consideration alongside workaday $25,000 family sedans for consumers in search of extra spice.

Function

The GTI's primary gauges are clear and have a restrained, premium look that sets them apart in this sometimes juvenile segment. The standard touchscreen radio interface is a nice idea but could use a few tweaks — for example, the iPod interface (also standard) makes scrolling through your playlists unnecessarily time-consuming, and navigating through the menus is sometimes less than intuitive. On the bright side, the base stereo is above average, delivering crisp highs and tight lows.

A more notable misstep is the climate control system's airflow knob, which has markings that are almost illegible without the benefit of nighttime illumination. In our real-world usability tests, the 2010 Volkswagen GTI's compact-looking cargo area somehow gulped down our standard golf bag and suitcase without issue. Given the generous rear passenger space, it came as no surprise that a rear-facing child safety seat fit easily behind the front seats.

Design/Fit and Finish

The new GTI's styling seems to have been poked and prodded in all the right ways. Gone is the Mk V's slightly overgrown look, replaced by tight sheet metal, sleeker headlights and a clipped front overhang. The standard 17-inch horseshoe-pattern alloy wheels look great, too.

Inside, the GTI is a couple four-ring badges short of Audi status. Materials are top-notch and the overall look is more entry-level luxury than hot hatch. Build quality has been a question mark for Volkswagen over the long term, but our test car was squeak- and rattle-free. The doors deserve specific praise for their classic Germanic closing thunk.

Who Should Consider This Vehicle

The 2010 Volkswagen GTI merits consideration by everyone from the sport-compact crowd to those looking for a reasonably priced and practical alternative to the Audi A3/A4 or BMW 3 Series. For people who like to drive, the GTI might be the ultimate affordable family car.




The manufacturer provided Edmunds this vehicle for the purposes of evaluation.

Model Year2010
MakeVolkswagen
ModelGTI
Style4dr Hatchback (2.0L 4cyl Turbo 6M)
Base Price$24,640
Price as Tested$24,839
Options on Test VehicleBluetooth Connectivity ($199)
Drive TypeFront-wheel drive
Transmission TypeSix-speed manual
Transmission and Axle Ratio (x:1)Being researched
Engine TypeTurbocharged direct-injected Inline-4 gasoline
Displacement (cc / cu-in)1,984cc (121cu-in)
Block/Head MaterialCast iron/aluminum
ValvetrainDouble overhead camshaft
Compression Ratio9.6
Redline (rpm)6,200
Horsepower (hp @ rpm)200 @ 5,100
Torque (lb-ft @ rpm)207 @ 1,800
Brake Type (front)12.3-inch ventilated disc with single-piston sliding caliper
Brake Type (rear)11.3-inch solid disc with single-piston sliding caliper
Steering SystemElectric-assist speed-proportional rack-and-pinion power steering
Steering Ratio15.6:1
Suspension Type (front)Independent, MacPherson struts, coil springs and stabilizer bar
Suspension Type (rear)Independent, multilink, coil springs and stabilizer bar
Tire Size (front)225/45R17 91H
Tire Size (rear)225/45R17 91H
Tire BrandContinental
Tire ModelContiPro Contact
Tire TypeAsymmetrical all-season
Wheel Size17-by-7 inches front and rear
Wheel Material (front/rear)Aluminum alloy
Manufacturer Curb Weight (lb)3,113
Curb Weight As Tested (lb)3,103
Weight Distribution, F/R (%)61/39
Recommended FuelPremium unleaded (recommended)
Fuel Tank Capacity (gal)14.5
EPA Fuel Economy (mpg)21 city/31 highway/25 combined
Edmunds Observed (mpg)15 worst/29 best/23 average (over 1,100 miles)
Testing Conditions

Temperature (Fahrenheit)77.5
Humidity12%
Elevation (ft)1,121
Wind0.75 Headwind
Performance

0 - 30 (sec)2.8
0 - 45 (sec)4.6
0 - 60 (sec)6.9
0 - 75 (sec)9.5
1/4 Mile (sec @ mph)14.9 @ 95.6
0-60 with 1-ft Rollout (sec)6.6
30 - 0 (ft)33
60 - 0 (ft)129
Braking RatingAverage
Slalom (mph)67.1
Skid Pad Leteral acceleration (g)0.84
Handling RatingAverage
Db @ Idle45.5
Db @ Full Throttle85.9
Db @ 70 mph Cruise68.2
Tester Comments

Acceleration CommentsOther than the sound and a satisfying shifter, this car utterly lacks anything exciting in the acceleration department. Only adequate power, really. Not what I'd call "fast."
Braking CommentsWhere'd the sports car go? Soft pedal until ABS engagement. Best stop is only 129 feet? Really? No fade, however.
Handling CommentsVW appears to have completely written the GTI off as a genuine driver's car. Beginning with the non-defeat stability control and ending with a suspension that's wildly underdamped, there's little left of the enthusiastic GTI we grew to love. Quick steering inputs are met with a huge yaw delay, and the standard all-season tires represent a huge compromise.
Specifications

Length (in)165.8
Width (in)70.0
Height (in)57.8
Wheelbase (in)101.5
Front Track (in)60.4
Rear Track (in)59.7
Turning Circle (ft)35.8
Legroom, front (in)41.2
Legroom, rear (in)35.5
Headroom, front (in)39.3
Headroom, rear (in)38.5
Shoulder Room, front (in)54.7
Shoulder Room, rear (in)54.6
Maximum Seating Capacity5
Cargo Volume (cu-ft)12.4
Cargo Volume, rear seats down (cu-ft)Being researched
Warranty

Bumper-to-Bumper3 years/36,000 miles
Power Train5 years/60,000 miles
Corrosion12 years/Unlimited miles
Roadside Assistance3 years/36,000 miles
Scheduled Maintenance3 years/36,000 miles
Safety

Front AirbagsStandard
Side AirbagsStandard dual front
Head AirbagsStandard front and rear
Knee AirbagsNot available
Antilock BrakesFour-wheel ABS
Electronic Brake EnhancementsBraking assist, electronic brakeforce distribution
Traction ControlStandard
Stability ControlStandard (non-defeat)
Rollover ProtectionNot available
Tire Pressure Monitoring SystemStandard tire-pressure monitoring
Emergency Assistance SystemNot available
NHTSA Crash Test Driver4 stars
NHTSA Crash Test Passenger4 stars
NHTSA Crash Test Side Front5 stars
NHTSA Crash Test Side Rear5 stars
NHTSA Rollover4 stars
IIHS OffsetNot tested
Read more

Car Design of the Year 2009

by Eric Gallina www.cardesignnews.com

Cadillac Converj concept (Detroit 2009). Click for larger images
Aston Martin Rapide (left); Ferrari 458 Italia (right)
Citroen Revolte (left); Honda U3-X (right)
Lincoln C concept (right); Infiniti Essence (right)
Nissan Qazana (left); Renault Zoe (right)
Citroen DS3 (left); Bentley Mulsanne (right0
Jaguar XJ (left); Lexus LFA (right)
Volkswagen Polo (left); Porsche Panamera (right)







For the next four weeks, Car Design News is asking you, our loyal readers, to vote for your favorite car designs from 2009. in 2008, you voted the BMW GINA as the Best Concept Design and the Chevrolet Camaro won the award for Best Production Design. BMW again took home the Best Concept Design Award for the Concept CS in 2007, while the Fiat 500 won the award in the Production Design category.

And so this year, for fear of having this award be derided for being bestowed upon the German brand yet again, we have agreed not to nominate the BMW Efficient Dynamics concept, which was a masterpiece in its own right. Sorry, Mr van Hooydonk, there's always next year...

Nominations for the Concept Design of the Year for 2009 are:

  • Cadillac Converj
  • Citroen Revolte
  • Honda U3-X
  • Infiniti Essence
  • Lincoln C concept
  • Nissan Qazana
  • Renault Zoe
  • Toyota FT-EV II
  • Volvo S60 concept
  • VW L1

Nominations for the Production Design of the Year for 2009 are:

  • Aston Martin Rapide
  • Bentley Mulsanne
  • Citroen DS3
  • Ferrari 458
  • Hyundai Sonata
  • Jaguar XJ
  • Lexus LFA
  • Opel Astra
  • Porsche Panamera
  • VW Polo

You can check out more on all of these cars by looking at the relevant auto show coverage from 2009. In addition, we've covered most of the cars in our Design Review or Design Development stories - you can find these in-depth reports under the relevant tabs on the homepage navbar.

Readers can vote just one time each so to be sure you get your say - vote online now!

Click here to vote for the Best Concept and Best Production cars of 2009

We'll be presenting the winners with an award at the 2010 Car Design Night in Geneva, so vote online for your favorite nominated design and watch for the story soon.



While 2009 will most certainly be remembered as a gloom riddled year - with the automotive industry stricken by the economic downturn and a slew of cutbacks - we encourage you to remember the few gems that graced the auto show circuit. So what was your favorite car design from 2009? Here's your chance to vote for your favorite designs, and have CDN present an award to the winning design teams at the forthcoming Geneva motor show.

Chris Bangle and Adrian van Hooydonk accept the 2008 Concept Car of the Year award for BMW's GINA concept
2008's Best Production Design award was presented to Dave Lyon of GM Design for the Chevrolet Camaro
Volvo S60 concept
Volkswagen L1 concept
Opel Astra

















































For the next four weeks, Car Design News is asking you, our loyal readers, to vote for your favorite car designs from 2009. in 2008, you voted the BMW GINA as the Best Concept Design and the Chevrolet Camaro won the award for Best Production Design. BMW again took home the Best Concept Design Award for the Concept CS in 2007, while the Fiat 500 won the award in the Production Design category.

And so this year, for fear of having this award be derided for being bestowed upon the German brand yet again, we have agreed not to nominate the BMW Efficient Dynamics concept, which was a masterpiece in its own right. Sorry, Mr van Hooydonk, there's always next year...

Nominations for the Concept Design of the Year for 2009 are:

  • Cadillac Converj
  • Citroen Revolte
  • Honda U3-X
  • Infiniti Essence
  • Lincoln C concept
  • Nissan Qazana
  • Renault Zoe
  • Toyota FT-EV II
  • Volvo S60 concept
  • VW L1

Nominations for the Production Design of the Year for 2009 are:

  • Aston Martin Rapide
  • Bentley Mulsanne
  • Citroen DS3
  • Ferrari 458
  • Hyundai Sonata
  • Jaguar XJ
  • Lexus LFA
  • Opel Astra
  • Porsche Panamera
  • VW Polo

You can check out more on all of these cars by looking at the relevant auto show coverage from 2009. In addition, we've covered most of the cars in our Design Review or Design Development stories - you can find these in-depth reports under the relevant tabs on the homepage navbar.

Readers can vote just one time each so to be sure you get your say - vote online now!

Click here to vote for the Best Concept and Best Production cars of 2009

We'll be presenting the winners with an award at the 2010 Car Design Night in Geneva, so vote online for your favorite nominated design and watch for the story soon.


Read more